top of page

Why I Am Starting To Hate 'The Mother Ship' Yet I Hate Nothing Else.

3 days ago
5 min read

Updated: 1 day ago


Apparently I am not alone, according to these latest figures.

How much do we hate them? Let us count the ways!

(I want you to comment below or send me an email to buddy@gatorbaitmedia.com and tell me how much and why.)

ESPN cut its people. Now the people are cutting ESPN.


ESPN has spent years showing loyal employees the door.


Now it gets to watch customers use it.


There is something almost touching about a corporation discovering that loyalty can disappear in both directions.


Especially one that has treated so much accumulated knowledge, credibility and goodwill as an unfortunate expense.


The latest number is 54 million!


That is how many U.S. pay-TV subscribers ESPN and ESPN2 reached as of September, according to Disney's annual report, as reported by Deadline. A year earlier, the figure was 61 million. Back in 2011, it was roughly 100 million.


Quite a slide for the Worldwide Leader. They can't seem to find a good tourniquet.


But before somebody in Bristol blames the whole thing on changing technology, let's separate two things: losing the cable bundle and losing touch.


One is an industry problem.


The other is a management achievement.


The people became the problem.


No, seven million households did not necessarily cancel cable because ESPN fired somebody they liked.


Those subscriber figures measure the shrinking pay-TV business, not seven million individual protest votes against the network.


But that doesn't mean ESPN gets to hide every questionable decision behind the phrase "cord-cutting," as if the company were an innocent pedestrian struck by a passing Roku.


Consider how it has treated the people who gave viewers a reason to care.


In 2023, Suzy Kolber was laid off after 27 years at ESPN. Jeff Van Gundy, Jalen Rose and Steve Young were among roughly 20 commentators and reporters cut in that round.


Twenty-seven years.


In sports, that gets you a banner in the rafters.


In corporate television, apparently, it gets you included in an efficiency exercise.


"Heartbreaking," Kolber called it. ESPN's explanation was that the decisions were "based more on overall efficiency than merit."


There's a lovely little message for the staff.


It's not that you weren't good enough. Being good enough is no longer the point.


These are businesses, of course. Nobody is entitled to a lifetime contract. Sometimes companies have to make cuts, and expensive television personalities are not exempt from economic reality.


But neither are executives exempt from judgment.


When you repeatedly dispose of familiar, accomplished people, you are making an editorial statement whether you recognize it or not. You are telling the audience which relationships you consider replaceable.


Eventually, the audience might agree with you.


How about yours.


A national network forgot where fans live


The more damaging mistake is the assumption that national reach automatically produces local understanding.


It doesn't.


You can beam a signal into Gainesville without knowing Gainesville. You can televise a game in the Swamp without understanding why people will still be arguing about a third-down call at breakfast on Tuesday.


A market is where you sell advertising.


A community is where people remember.


ESPN once seemed interested in that distinction. It recruited newspaper reporters to cover individual teams, cities and conferences. Then its cutbacks swept away people who supplied precisely that knowledge. The 2017 cuts included Dallas columnist Jean-Jacques Taylor, baseball reporter Mark Saxon and college football reporters Jesse Temple and Austin Ward, among many others.


Including the very popular, talented NFL reporter Ed Werder.


That is not merely reducing head count.


That is cutting the roots and congratulating yourself on how much lighter the tree has become.


Local knowledge isn't a graphic package. It isn't a visiting studio crew discovering that, yes, the home fans are passionate.


It is knowing whom to call after the press conference ends. Knowing which answer needs a follow-up. Knowing the difference between a genuine development and a coach spraying air freshener over a problem.


It is also knowing that fans have interests beyond whatever argument has been assigned to the afternoon shouting shift.


I haven't gotten mad enough to throw anything or curse at the TV, but I almost did the other night when ESPN decided to take off the Florida-Miami basketball game – the season opener featuring the nation's No. 1 team, in favor of… The ManningCast on Monday Night Football? Are you kidding me?


A Gator fan doesn't need a national network to flatter him. He or she needs it to understand what it is talking about.


There is a difference between covering a place and using it as scenery.


You cannot lay off your way to credibility.


The warning signs were hardly hidden.


After the 2017 layoffs, ESPN's own public editor wrote that the cuts had dealt "a painful blow" to its newsgathering capabilities. Reporters, columnists and other established journalists were among those shown the door.


Think about the logic.


Sports journalism depends on access, experience, sources and trust.


So, naturally, start by cutting people who have spent years acquiring them.


It is the restaurant strategy of saving money by firing the cooks, then wondering why customers aren't more excited about the new menu design.


The people behind the cameras matter, too. Producers. Editors. Researchers. The staff members whose names viewers never learn but whose work helps keep a broadcast from sounding like three people arguing over a television in an airport bar.


The 2017 reductions were not confined to recognizable faces; a later round hit approximately 150 positions, with production personnel among those affected.


Those people are not incidental to the product.


They are the product, even when they don't get the chair with the network logo.


The bundle stopped making the decision.


For years, the cable bundle gave ESPN a remarkable advantage: it occupied an extraordinarily valuable place inside a package that subscribers bought as a whole. As that system shrinks, the network has to fight harder for customers who have more ways to spend their money and attention.


That is a business challenge.


It ought to be a humility lesson.


Because a customer making an active choice is different from a household arriving inside a bundle.


That customer might like the games and dislike everything surrounding them. He might miss a reporter the network considered expendable. He or she might decide that another panel delivering another manufactured argument is not essential household equipment.


None of that proves ESPN's layoffs caused its subscriber losses.


It does raise a question the balance sheet cannot answer:


When people are finally free to choose, what have you done to make them choose you?


Better yet, what have you done to make them miss you?


You cannot spend years treating experience as excess baggage and then act bewildered when the audience finds the product easier to leave behind.


You cannot tell employees that yesterday's contributions don't guarantee tomorrow's place, then expect customers to renew out of gratitude for the old days.


ESPN is entitled to run its business.


Fans are entitled to run their households.


And somewhere, a former subscriber may be conducting a little efficiency exercise of his own.


Nothing personal, Bristol.


Based more on overall efficiency than merit.


Give me your thoughts.


3 Comments


Jim
2 days ago

The GREED of ESPN is on full display. Make as much money as they can for their CEO and Stockholders and care nothing about what those who watch college football want. 24 games makes zero sense. Either 16 or 32. No at home games; no weeks off; one playoff game per location; add to locations by adding existing bowl sites; and KEEP the conference playoffs. The current approach of ESPN is as bad as the decision of Congress to impose NIL with no firm rules in place. I want to be able to enjoy collage football again. When I was @ UF my roommate was a guard on the football team --- just very happy to be able …

Like

Rusty Neff
2 days ago

Where to start? A previous article by you, Buddy Martin, regarding ESPN and their decision to pay excessive salaries for their two star actors (not announcers, one being Pat McAfee) and cut back on the number of employees that helped ESPN to be relevant in sports, really opened my eyes to ESPN’s business practices. However, what I hate most about ESPN is that they first get the SEC to agree to be their lone network for SEC sports, and then they stab the SEC in the back by agreeing to a 24 team football playoff, which the SEC was decisively not in favor of, as well as all of college football’s fans. As GatorBait reported earlier by one commenter -…

Like

Jdelaney
3 days ago

Buddy, years ago as I got up into management, I got to talking with a hospital CEO. General Motors had given labor unions a huge pay increase, greatly damaging the company. The CEO said: “It is always management’s fault. No one else. Not labor or employees, not the government, not the competition. It is always management’s fault when things go wriong.” Sometimes outside events cause major issues, such as 9/11 or a hurricane. ESPN got greedy, and pigs get fat but hogs get slaughtered. Love your stuff, Buddy. Go Gators.


Like
bottom of page