What If There Was No CFB -- Only The SEC ?

 

When Greed Dims the North Star

There’s a moment in every great institution’s history when the money gets loud enough to drown out the wisdom. When the smell of it curls around the room like cheap cigar smoke and suddenly the men in the expensive suits start looking at each other across the table with dollar signs where their eyes used to be.

We have arrived at that moment in college football.

The sport’s North Star — the one that has guided it through conference upheavals, television revolutions, antitrust skirmishes, and the slow combustion of the NCAA — is the Southeastern Conference. Not because it’s perfect. Lord knows it isn’t. But because for decades it operated on the bedrock understanding that greatness is built through competition, tradition, and yes, the kind of geographic and cultural identity that makes a rivalry game feel like life and death on a Saturday afternoon in October.

Now here comes greed, dressed up in leverage, threatening to blow all of that up. At first it sounds inviting, the SEC only, and then logic prevails.

And remarkably, it took a couple of United States senators to say out loud what some of the most powerful men in college athletics are either too timid or too compromised to say themselves.

---

“One of the real risks is the SEC and Big Ten joining together.”

That’s Sen. Ted Cruz, R-Texas — a man not exactly known as the guardian of the little guy — explaining why he and Sen. Maria Cantwell built an anti-super league provision directly into their bipartisan Protect College Sports Act, introduced just days ago.

Let that settle for a moment. A Texas Republican and a Washington Democrat agreed on something.

And what they agreed on is that college football’s two wealthiest conferences — the SEC, sitting on a record $1.03 billion in annual distributions, and the Big Ten, doling out $1.37 billion — cannot be allowed to merge, consolidate, or absorb each other into some gilded, self-governing, financially impenetrable super league that effectively ends the American college football model as we have known and loved it.

The bill bars any conference clearing more than $1 billion in annual revenue from merging with, acquiring, or consolidating with another conference. That is precisely two conferences. You know their names.

Twenty-six of 32 Division I conference commissioners signed a letter to Cruz and Cantwell expressing enthusiastic support for the bill.

Greg Sankey did not sign it. Neither did Big Ten Commissioner Tony Petitti.

Now, I want to be careful here, because Greg Sankey is not the villain in this story.

Sankey has, at the SEC Spring Meetings this week in Destin, conducted himself with his customary measured deliberateness. He’ll tell you — correctly — that the SEC is the strongest football league in America by a country mile. He’s right about that. He’ll tell you the conference has earned every dollar it distributes because it delivers the best product, the biggest brands, the most passionate fanbases in the country. He’s right about that too.

He prefers a 16-team playoff over 24. He’s even right about that — though you’d be hard-pressed to find anyone willing to say it plainly in a room full of coaches who see a 24-team field as job insurance.

But Sankey finds himself at a crossroads this week, in more ways than one. And the direction the SEC takes from here — not just on the legislation, but on the philosophical question underneath it — will determine whether the conference remains college football’s true compass or becomes merely its richest bully.

---

The whispers aren’t whispers anymore.

Iowa State Athletic Director Jamie Pollard has essentially called out the power two conferences, challenging them to stop threatening to break from the NCAA and just do it already. His message, blunt as a two-by-four: put up or shut up.

Here’s the dirty little secret: the SEC and Big Ten have been playing this threat like a fiddle for a decade. Every time the conversation turns uncomfortable — roster limits, transfer rules, revenue sharing with athletes — out comes the nuclear option. We’ll just leave. Well, guess what? After years of leveraging that threat into favorable legislation, the Senate has now called the bluff and built a legal wall around it.

Any separation attempt, the bill makes clear, happens without congressional support. And given that the SEC-backed SCORE Act appears to be sputtering in the House, there is no friendly legislative runway available either.

Meanwhile, the Big Ten and SEC can’t even agree among themselves whether the CFP should be 16 or 24 teams. You think those two conferences, with their separate television empires, their separate egos, their separate traditions, are going to voluntarily marry each other and share the proceeds?

The greedheads want you to believe they can. Because threatening to do it is worth more than actually doing it.

---

Here is the truth that lives underneath all of this noise:

The SEC is college football’s North Star not because of its television contract. It’s because of autumn Saturdays in Gainesville and Tuscaloosa and Baton Rouge and Athens. It’s because of rivalries that predate television itself. It’s because there is a cultural soul embedded in this league that no merger, no super conference, no closed-system carve-out can replicate — and that soul is precisely what dies first when the money becomes the entire point.

Greg Sankey knows this. Deep down, in whatever place a commissioner keeps his convictions, he knows the way.

The question is whether the greedheads get loud enough to dim it.

College football doesn’t need a super league. It needs a spine.

Here’s hoping the men in those expensive suits find one.

---

Buddy Martin has covered college athletics for more than five decades.